MCI’s in-principle approval to bridge course of MBBS after BDS / TAMIL NADU –TheHindu Centre has no right to conduct NEET: Veeramani /Millennium Post  NEET: Centre mulls upper age limit for medical admission, Pradip Chatterjee,20 Oct 2017

MCI’s in-principle approval to bridge course of MBBS after BDS

By Vikas Vaidya,

Joint Study Group of MCI-DCI under the Chairmanship of Dr Vedprakash Mishra specifies certain guidelines for the course

Accepting the proposal of Dental Council of India (DCI) in principle for allowing bridge course for students of Batchelor of Dental Surgery (BDS) to do three year MBBS, Medical Council of India (MCI) has constituted Joint Study Group (JSG) to specify the guidelines to run the course. The Committee, under the Chairmanship of Dr Vedprakash Mishra, Chairman of Academic Committee of MCI, has chalked out the modalities on which the work is to be done.

Dr Dibyendu Mazumdar, DCI President informed that DCI had brought out a regulation of allowing a student to go for a three years’ condensed course of MBBS after BDS. This will qualify them to also practice general medicine. He was in Nagpur for the 42nd Annual Congress of Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons of India and Scientifically Sponsored Meeting by EACMFS being held at Empress Palace.

When contacted Dr Vedprakash Mishra about the development of bridge course, he said, “DCI had sent a draft regulation to MCI. It was sent to academic committee under my Chairmanship for review. We reviewed it. We pointed out certain things. Accordingly a Joint Study Group of representatives from MCI and DCI was formed and I was made Chairman. A meeting to this regard was conducted recently.”

Dr Mishra further said, “The curriculum proposed by DCI is old so we have to modify it. Secondly, MCI has proposed new competency based integrated course that was adopted by council and approved by Government of India. This bridge course proposed by DCI can be included in this integrated one provided that competency need to be incorporated. The contents of MBBS course that are taught to BDS students should need to be find out to get them excluded from the new bridge course.”

The another aspect pointed out by Dr Mishra is this bridge course has not mentioned the point of internship. As the MBBS student has to do internship so the student doing this bridge course need to go for internship of one year. Since BDS is regulated by DCI and MBBS by MCI, the question arises that who would run this bridge course. Dr Mishra committee will study all these modalities for Post-BDS-MBBS bridge course to evolve operational guidelines. Dr Mishra said, “This proposal is good enough.”

The committee will be headed by Dr Vedprakash Mishra as Convenor while Dr Keshvan Kutti Nair, Dr R K Sharma will be other members.

Physical disability won’t prevent deserving candidate from becoming doctor

The Medical Council of India will open up admissions to 21 categories of even severely disabled candidates for graduate and post-graduate medical courses.

INDIA Updated: Nov 05, 2017 Hindustan Times, New Delh

Physical disability will no longer be grounds to prevent a person from becoming a doctor, bringing the curtain down on a two-decade-long battle between specially-abled students and India’s medical studies regulator.

The Medical Council of India (MCI) will now allow 21 categories of even severely disabled candidates to take next year’s graduate and post-graduate medical courses, a landmark shift in its policy after a severe stricture from the Supreme Court in August.

These include blindness, low-vision, hearing impairment, locomotor disability, dwarfism, intellectual disability, multiple sclerosis and muscular dystrophy.

MCI secretary Reena Nayyar told Hindustan Times that a decision was made at the council’s general body meeting on October 31 to implement in toto the country’s newly revised disability law.

“The ministry of social justice and empowerment is in the process of framing rules to specify medical job roles for different categories of disability,” she said.

Until now, the MCI allowed only candidates with below 70% disability of the lower limbs to study medicine, although the condition contravened all disability-related laws in the country, forcing such students to wage individual legal battles for admission to medical schools.

The council argued that people with severe disability were not good enough to study medicine.

In its October meeting, MCI members resolved that times had changed and with progress in science it did not make sense to bar disabled people from becoming doctors any more.

The MCI’s decades-old stand barring physically challenged students from its courses reflected a wider apathy in Indian society towards the disabled and elderly who face difficulty in accessing everything from education to public transport.

India’s first disability law was written as late as 1995. It gave 3% reservation in education to people with seven kinds of disabilities, although the legislation was seen by many experts as inadequate. Worse, the law was more observed in the breach.

That law was strengthened and replaced by a new one this year, raising the quota for disabled people to 5% and the categories of disability by another 14.

It took a rap on the knuckles from the Supreme Court earlier this year for the MCI to finally come around.

In August, a student with thalassemia was allowed by the Supreme Court to take admission in a medical college. The court came down heavily on the MCI as well, asking it to implement the laws in letter and spirit to uphold social justice.

“We constituted a committee headed by Dr Ved Prakash Mishra. The committee recommended complete implementation of the act,” a top MCI official who attended the meeting said. The official was not authorised to speak to journalists.

“The committee felt that such discrimination doesn’t exit internationally so we should allow them in medical profession for the sake of social justice.”

Centre has no right to conduct NEET: Veeramani


DK says IMC Act exceeds law-making powers of Parliament

The Dravidar Kazhagam on Monday opened a new line of attack against the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test, claiming that it had unearthed evidence to question the test’s legal standing.

In a statement issued to The Hindu, DK president K. Veeramani said that neither the Central government nor the Medical Council of India had the power to conduct NEET. Mr. Veeramani said that he was confident that any petition challenging the Indian Medical Council (Amendment) Act, 2016 in the Supreme Court would have been successful, leading to the cancellation of NEET.

Mr. Veeramani argued that the IMC Act, 2016 exceeds the law-making powers of Parliament. “Powers to decide on the regulations to the admission of students and conducting examinations come under the exclusive domain of universities,” he said. The Constitution states the power to incorporate and establish universities.


“The Central government wrongly assumed the existence of power and has interfered in the exclusive legislative domain of States,” he said.

The DK president also said that the NEET was not applicable to Tamil Nadu due to a 2007 Act passed in the Assembly to abolish entrance tests to all professional degree courses.

“The Act also got the assent of the President of India, which makes the Act equivalent to the Act legislated in the Parliament of India,” he said.

Mr. Veeramani said seeking exemption from NEET was not charity but claiming the rights of States. “It is the urgent duty of any individual or organisation having identical views against NEET, to challenge it in a court of law,” he said.

                                                                           Millennium Post

NEET: Centre mulls upper age limit for medical admission

Pradip Chatterjee,20 Oct 2017

Kolkata: The Centre is planning to introduce the maximum age limit for candidates seeking admission in medical colleges through the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET) in the country.

The Union Health Ministry has recently asked the Medical Council of India (MCI), the highest regulatory body for medical education in the country, to fix 25 years as the upper age limit for general category students and 30 years for reserved category students.

A high-level meeting was held between the Union health ministry officials and the MCI officials, where MCI was asked to formulate a policy so that the age-limit can be implemented throughout the country. The theory the Centre is keen on bringing in had never implemented by the MCI since its inception.

The Supreme Court while hearing a case on the implementation of the maximum age limit in medical admission last year asked the Centre not to introduce any such age limit. The Centre had tried to introduce the age limit the previous year as well.

Those against it said that the introduction of age limit of candidates in medical admission is against the Constitution of India. Dr A K Maity, who had written a letter to the Prime Minister recently against the implementation of any age limit in medical admission, pointed out that while hearing a case relating to the upper age limit for LLB examination, the Apex Court in March this year ruled that there will be no age limit for LLB examination. It had also stayed Bar Council of India’s (BCI) notification fixing age limit for law courses.

The Union health ministry also asked the MCI to provide appropriate amendment regulations in consultation with its Oversight Committee (OC). The OC was formed by the order of the Supreme Court for monitoring the activities of the MCI. The Centre had argued in the court that they were keen on implementing the age limit for medical aspirants to check cheating by a section of candidates in medical examinations. The Centre claimed that they had found that the comparatively older medical aspirants were found to be involved in cheating.

But the AIPMT/PD 2015 list published by the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) said that two candidates out of total 53 candidates found to be involved in cheating were above the age of 25 while the rest were all below 25 years of age.

UN Rally by American Tamil Diaspora Demand End to NEET and

Justice for Anitha


US Tamil Diaspora

Oct 05, 2017, 09:02 ET

NEW YORK, Oct. 5, 2017 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ — US Tamil Diaspora members held a peaceful protest in front of the United Nations in New York denouncing the Indian government’s imposition of a discriminatory qualifying exam known as NEET for medical student admissions at state level. They also demanded justice for the Tamil Nadu premedical student Anitha who ended her life when NEET squashed her dreams of becoming a doctor.

The protest by Tamils was aimed at gaining the attention of the Indian External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj who was attending the proceedings of the UN General Assembly. The September 23rd protest was well attended by Tamils from New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Pennsylvania, Delaware and Virginia who wore masks depicting Anitha and holding Indian and American flags. They chanted slogans against NEET and seeking justice for Anitha.

“In India, laws and regulations are enacted without sufficient consultations and implemented with swiftness”, lamented a protester, Mr. DS. Kannan. “The imposition of NEET is a classic example of this swiftness which is eroding the gains of social justice that forms the very core of Tamilnadu.”

Anitha, a 17-year-old student hailing from Ariyalur, a village in the State of Tamilnadu has become largely the face of NEET. Fast being known as the first victim of NEET, Anitha’s score of 1176 out of 1200 did not guarantee a spot on the state medical colleges. Promises by Central and Tamilnadu State Governments to exempt the state from NEET did not materialize. It is feared that NEET could undo decades of public health achievements by Tamilnadu.

As a direct outcome of Anitha’s death, Tamils across America have organized and run many spontaneous demonstrations. Candlelight vigils were observed in more than 40 states with many protestors holding placards to express their views against NEET.

Peaceful protests were held across Washington, Chicago, New York, San Francisco, Raleigh and Atlanta and in front of the Indian Embassies garnering attention.

A petition has been sent by protestors to the Indian Embassy in Washington on September 22nd requesting Tamilnadu to be exempted from NEET, and to devolve education from Central Governance to State Governance.

 See here for video of the protest:

 For further information, please contact Durai Sundarackannan at or 302-521-4623


MBBS admissions: MCI waits for info on 12,000

students from 97 colleges

The Medical Council of India is still waiting for details on 12,000 students from 97 colleges across the country.

Sep 28, 2017

Nearly a month after medical colleges completed admission formalities for undergraduate medical (MBBS) course on August 31, the Medical Council of India (MCI) is still waiting for details on 12,000 students from 97 colleges across the country.

Repeated reminders from the MCI to these colleges have failed to evoke any response.

The MCI mandates sharing admission-related details so that it can check compliance.

The delay from colleges in sending information assumes significance in the wake of the medical education regulator cancelling admission of 778 MBBS students — all in their second year of the course — in various private colleges in Puducherry after a probe found their colleges had not complied with the counselling process.

“Had the irregularities been identified in 2016 itself, at least these candidates could have appeared in NEET in 2017 and sought admission afresh,” says Thiru M Narayanassamy, president, Puducherry All Centac Students Parents Association.

An MCI source said, “Often, colleges admit students beyond their permitted capacity or admission date or in violation of other norms. If the colleges don’t submit details on time, the ultimate sufferer is the candidate.”

“There are about 460 colleges with about 65,000 seats. There are procedural delays in MCI as well but if the colleges comply with the guidelines, it will make our job easy,” the source added.


SC opens doors for colour-blind medical aspirants

Sep 24, 2017,

The Supreme Court has opened the doors for colour-blind students to pursue MBBS course by ordering the admission of two such candidates, who have scored high marks in the entrance examination, for the next academic year.

Terming its action as “transcendental importance of justice”, the apex court said that peculiar facts and circumstances of the case required it to invoke special powers under Article 142 of the Constitution.

The two students had secured high marks in the entrance examination conducted by the Tripura government in 2015 during the pre-NEET period.

Without any statutory provision barring students from pursuing MBBS course, various colleges and Medical Council of India (MCI) were arbitrarily denying admissions to candidates suffering from Colour Vision Deficiency (CVD), popularly called colour blindness.

Both MCI and the Tripura Medical College had initially objected to their admission into MBBS course as the two students suffered from CVD despite having qualified in the entrance examination.

“Keeping in view the transcendental importance of justice which is writ large in this case, we direct that the appellants shall be admitted in the MBBS course in the respondent No.2-College for the academic year 2018-2019 and the quota from the said year shall be reduced by two seats,” a bench headed by Chief Justice Dipak Misra said.

Also See: CBI takes over Ryan School murder case, Haryana police summons school owners

The apex court had on March 23 constituted an experts committee to ascertain whether colour blindness affected the prospects of students aspiring to become doctors.

In its report, the committee had opined that “Colour Vision Deficiency does not have any embargo of any type whatsoever” and suggested the incorporation of a suitable provision in the Graduate Medical Education to the effect that a person with visual disability of category I and above shall not be eligible to pursue Graduate Medical Education.

It had also recommended that “testing of Colour Vision Deficiency by Ishihara test be compulsorily incorporated in the format of General Physical Examination of the Student, so that all medical students with suspect colour vision should be aware of severity of their deficiency before entering the medical course, and the kind of problems it may pose in the career they have opted”.

The committee had also said that as per current global practices, there was no policy of regulating entry of medical aspirants to study and practice of the medical profession based on colour vision deficiency.

It has said that CVD nowadays was a common problem and does not significantly impact a person’s ability to become a doctor.

The MCI had objected to the admission of students with CVD in MBBS course, in the wake of report of the expert committee.

It had said that certain guidelines are required to be framed in accordance with the report of the Committee for controlling speciality and super-speciality courses as far as the CVD category is concerned.

The bench had on July 31 asked the MCI to apprise it whether the students can be admitted to MBBS course. Both the students had initially challenged the denial of admission by the college during counselling in 2015 before Tripura High Court, but had failed to get any relief.


The students then moved apex court challenging the high court order saying the MCI had not framed any regulation debarring them from seeking admission and contending that denial of admission to them constituted violation of the constitutional guarantee of equality.


 In AIIMS leak case listed before Delhi High Court, AIIMS asked for 4 weeks time to file a reply on the action taken by AIIMS. CBI has filed a status report in closed envelop on investigation. Next date 25.10.2017. In AIIMS leak case listed before Delhi High Court, AIIMS asked for 4 weeks time to file a reply on the action taken by AIIMS. CBI has filed a status report in closed envelop on investigation. Next date 25.10.2017

MCI ‘cancels’ admission of 778 MBBS students in


Discharge students admitted in Puducherry

colleges bypassing centac: MCI

                               DECCAN CHRONICLE.

                              Published Sep 14, 2017,

Puducherry: The Medical Council of India (MCI) issued directions to the health secretary and department director to discharge students admitted to MBBS courses in seven private medical colleges and deemed universities in the Union Territory under the management quota, bypassing the Centralised Admission Committee (Centac) in the academic year 2016-17. A letter from Rajendra Wabale, joint secretary of MCI, states that these medical colleges failed to show’ any evidence of transparency and fairness in the admission process  and violated Supreme Court directions. The MCI order means that the admission of these students virtually stands cancelled.

The UT All Centac Students Parents Association had lodged a complaint with the MCI stating that MBBS admission for 2016-17 was illegal. Lt Governor Kiran Bedi had also lodged a complaint stating that merit was not followed in medical admissions after which the complaint was placed before a monitoring sub-committee formed by the MCI.

The committee found that the deemed universities had not prepared a combined merit list of students who qualified in Neet, and therefore the Supreme Court’s direction to maintain transparency and fairness in the admission process had been violated.

These universities were not ready to be part of the common counselling organised by the government formed committee, the MCI letter said.

In the case of admission to seven private medical colleges in the UT, the committee found that only a limited number of students were given admission through Centac and the others admitted on the basis of Neet without following transparency in the process.  The monitoring sub-committee recommended discharge of all students who were not admitted through Centac and cancellation of all admissions made after September 30, 2016,  the last date of admission. This was later approved by the MCI. “Submit compliance within two weeks, failing which necessary action will be taken on the issue,” the MCI letter said.

                             Millennium post

HS toppers urge scrapping NEET; want states to

                              conduct own exams

                           Team MP |  5 Sep 2017

Kolkata: The toppers of Higher Secondary examination who failed to secure a medical seat and have vehemently opposed the implementation of NEET, now raised a demand to scrap it, allowing the states to conduct their own entrance examination.

The students also urged the state government to raise the issue with the Centre and take necessary steps so that the Union Health ministry cancels the implementation of NEET allowing the respective state governments to hold their own examination

If the Centre continues with this single level entrance examination in the country, it would be disastrous for the students appearing in the vernacular languages.

The students said that the NEET’s design is starkly favourable to the CBSE syllabi — in fact, it is tailor-made to the advantage of CBSE students and thus create an educational imbalance and students from state educational systems remain mostly deprived.

 The examination was devised in English, extended to Hindi but those educated in vernaculars are the worst sufferers.

The HS toppers also viewed that the common entrance exam may spell doom for the majority of medical aspirants from the state boards. The poor students who were unable to afford the exorbitant training required to be engaged with national examinations with mechanical expertise would not be able to compete with the urban students studying in CBSE boards. A single level examination cannot be implemented throughout the country.

There has been vehement opposition from students, doctors, parents, non-commercial educationists, political parties and even social justice organizations regarding the same. The governments of non-Hindi states have also opposed the move.

It may be mentioned here that around 97.48 percent MBBS seats throughout the country have been filled by English medium students.

 Swayangprabha Shaw, who failed to secure a medical seat despite ranking second in the Higher Secondary examination, said there is an over-arching fear that NEET will provide a huge advantage to students of Delhi-headquartered boards such as the Central Board of Secondary Education.

Students from these boards also tend to be more urban, upper caste, rich and less likely to be from non-Hindi states, apart from the principal language of non-Hindi states not being their first language.

 Debasish Saha, who ranked eighth in the HS but did not get a seat, alleged in the name of NEET that the state boards were being forced to emulate the CBSE syllabi.

West Bengal board students who always achieve good results in the state-level medical entrance perform pathetically in the NEET. Due to this, the CBSE syllabus “pattern” has become the standard, while there are many other standard boards across the country.

Noureen Hossain, ranked eighth in the Higher Secondary exam, said the CBSE-based NEET syllabus favours those who have undergone their schooling and training in the CBSE/Indian School Certificate framework, the syllabus being a vital component of that framework.

 State boards with syllabi that differ considerably from the CBSE are at an unfair disadvantage — they have to change or perish for absolutely no fault of their own.

 Dr A K Maity, who was among the five doctors who wrote to the Prime Minister in this regard, said CBSE lacks the infrastructure to conduct a nationwide entrance examination. It is not easy for a board like CBSE to conduct a single medical entrance examination in 10 different languages in the country.



After SC orders, MP cancels medical  & dental


TNN | Updated: Aug 30, 2017, 07:07 IST

BHOPAL: Madhya Pradesh government on Tuesday cancelled the counselling and admissions to MBBS and BDS courses in private and government medical and dental colleges of the state in compliance with the Supreme Court orders.

The apex court on Tuesday rejected the plea of the state challenging the MP high court’s August 24 decision on admission of non-domicile candidates and directed the state to start the counselling process afresh.

The SC also directed the state to ‘redraw’ the merit list and complete the admission process in 10 days.

“Counselling would take place again. The apex court has given 10 days to complete the process. New schedule would be made public on Wednesday,” said MP principal secretary, health Gauri Singh.

DME sources said fresh counselling process would begin from August 31. Students have been advised to check the schedule and details on MP Online portal and DME website.

Sources said that of the 313 students whose domicile status is under cloud, 79 MBBS candidates who are assumed to have taken admissions are likely to be cancelled. A fresh merit list is being prepared by the DME. It was not clear how many rounds of counselling would take place. There are about 3,000 MBBS and BDS seats in private and government medical and dental colleges.


After first round of counselling an estimated 95% of seats in government colleges were said to be filled.

“The issue affects government and private medical colleges. After two rounds of counselling, some students from other states sought admission claiming to be domiciles of Madhya Pradesh. MPHC decision maintained that domicile would be determined by NEET form status,” said advocate Aditya Sanghi.

Government advocate Saurabh Mishra informed the apex court had rejected the petition of state government and given MP government 10-days to complete the admission process.

Court had directed that information furnished by a candidate shall be determined by NEET form in respect to the residence as per Rule 3(5) of the admission rules. Information bulletin published by CBSE would be followed by the DME.




Millennium post

Notice issued by state Health dept: Medical

aspirant moves HC

Team MP |  23 Aug 2017

Kolkata: A medical aspirant, who has not been allotted a seat after first and second round of medical counseling, moved a writ petition at the Calcutta high court on Wednesday challenging a notice issued by the state Health department which the petitioner has claimed to be in contrary to an order issued by the Supreme Court.

According to the Apex Court, the order said that the students who were already allotted a seat in undergraduate medical or dental courses in the first and second round of counselling will not be given any chance to take part in the manual counseling.

This is because the other eligible candidates who were not yet allotted seats in the previous two counselling may be deprived if the candidates who have already booked seats get an opportunity to participate in the manual counselling.

It may be mentioned that the Supreme Court had given detailed guidelines on the admission of candidates who had cleared the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET). Following the court order, the state Health department had issued a notification on July 7 where it was mentioned that those who were allotted seats in the first two rounds of counselling will not be given an opportunity to take part in the manual counselling which is scheduled to take place on August 26.

But the notification issued by the Director of Medical Education on August 18 was contrary to previous notice issued by the Health department on July 7. The latest notification was also against the Supreme Court order. In the notice issued by the Director of Medical Education on August 18, it was mentioned that those who were already allotted seats in the first two round of counsellings may take part in the manual round of counselling if they desire so which is in gross violation of the Apex Court order, as argued by the lawyer of the petitioner, Md Alauddin Mandal.

Mandal said that if the students who were already allotted seats in the first and second round of counsellings are given an option to appear in the manual counseling, hundreds of successful candidates who were not allotted seats may be deprived of a seat.

A section of students will try to opt for a medical seat in better colleges after securing a seat while the other section will be deprived.




8-yr-old labourer writes to Prez seeking medical seat after failing to get admission in pvt college

 Pradip Chatterjee |  22 Aug 2017 11:01 PM


Kolkata: After failing to secure admission in a private medical college for the fourth consecutive time this year due to lack of funds despite clearing the national level entrance NEET, 2017, with around 62 percent marks, a 48-year-old daily wage labourer from a distant village in Nadia wrote to the President of India seeking a medical seat. His main aim, he says, would be to treat patients in his village where there is no registered medical practitioners; only quacks, sorcerers and exorcists. Read This – After Middle East, state gears up to export vegetables to Europe, America What Pradip Halder, a resident of bordering areas of Pratappur village under Krishnaganj police station in Nadia has done at the age of 48 is not only a challenge for any medical aspirant but his indomitable spirit makes him stand out to be an inspiration amongst others. Whether he will be able to get recognition in the form of a medical degree or not is a different issue, what he had aimed for nearly two decades, is now up to the consideration of President Ram Nath Kovind. Halder has appeared in the medical entrance examination for 17 times, be it the state medical entrance examination or the national one like NEET. The Supreme Court’s judgment had also gone in his favour as it had removed the upward age limit of a candidate to become a doctor. This paved his way to appear in the NEET 2017 and he came out with flying colours. Read This – All party meet: ‘Awaiting official invites’ In his letter to the President, Halder said he has passed the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET) 2017, undergraduate level for medical admission for 2017-18 academic session in Scheduled Caste category with 61.39 percentage marks. “With the marks what I have secured, a candidate is eligible to find a place in the undergraduate medical admission. But, I am not getting a seat in the private medical colleges despite a rank as my poverty has become a barrier to my goal,” Halder mentions in the letter. Halder has five members in his family — his wife, three children and ailing mother — who are all dependent on him. He has a monthly income of around Rs 1000, as he mentioned in his letter. He has made a prevent appeal to President Kovind urging him to provide him a medical seat as a President’s nominee as he wants to treat patients in his village which lacks a registered medical practitioner. The trained doctors are available at a primary health centre situated more than 20 km away from his village. Hence, the villagers have to depend on quacks, exorcists and sorcerers who are in rampant practice there. He had appeared in Madhyamik examination in 1986 from Khalboalia High School and secured 59.2 percent marks. Despite being a topper in school, he had failed to pursue higher secondary immediately after completing Madhyamik due to severe financial constraints. He again resumed studies in 1998 and passed the Higher Secondary examination from National Open Schooling in 2000. While talking to Millennium Post over telephone, Halder owed his success to a city-based doctor and former teacher of SSKM, Dr A. K.  Maity who assisted him immensely to help him secure a spot in the national level medical entrance examination.

 Gujarat mulls ordinance to bypass NEET

TNN / Aug 19, 2017

GANDHINAGAR: Gujarat government is seriously considering the option of passing an ordinance in Gujarat similar to the ‘Tamil Nadu Admission to MBBS and BDS Courses Bill-2017′. The Gujarat government hopes that this will end the disquiet among students and their parents over the all-India National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test (NEET) for admission to medical and dental colleges across the country.
Tamil Nadu had passed the new bill in February 2017 exempting students of the state from taking the NEET for admission to medical and dental colleges across the country. The new bill allows admision of students to undergraduate medical courses based on their marks in Class 12 board examinations. However, the Tamil Nadu bill is yet to be approved by the President of India.
Sources in the Gujarat government said that as the matter of NEET is pending before the Supreme Court, the government does not have many options to address students and parents’ concern. The sources, however, said that the Gujarat government is seriously considering promulgating a new ordinance like the Tamil Nadu law. It is possible that the ordinance may also face legal hurdles but, politically, it could highlight the state government’s genuine concern.
Gujarat education minister Bhupendrasinh Chudasama, confirmed that the state government was thinking of passing such an ordinance to resolve the NEET problem.
“We have referred the matter to the attorney general for legal advice. We are waiting for the judgement of the Supreme Court on this issue. We are hopeful of a favourable solution,” Chudasama said.


15 August 2017|E-Paper

NEET: Congress wants ordinance for separate merit list of Gujarat students

The Congress delegation demanded the state government prepare a separate NEET merit list for Gujarati medium students by bringing an ordinance as soon as possible

Ahmedabad: Expressing apprehension that the students who had appeared for NEET in Gujarati might be at disadvantage compared to those attempted the all-India medical test in English during admissions, the Congress leaders on Monday called on Governor O P Kohli and sought his intervention.

The Congress delegation, led by the state party chief Bharatsinh Solanki, demanded the state government prepare a separate merit list for the Gujarati medium students by bringing an ordinance as soon as possible.

During the meeting with the governor in Gandhinagar, the Congress leaders said the party would support the ruling BJP if the state government brings an ordinance for a separate merit list for the Gujarat board students who attempted the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET) in the regional language.

The Congress told the governor that due to a “discrepancy”, the NEET question papers in Gujarati were more difficult than those in English, the party said in a release. According to Congress, as many as 47,583 students of the Gujarat board, who had given the test in Gujarati, would be “subjected to injustice in the admission”.

At present, the first round of the admission process as per NEET merit list is completed. Congress alleged the Centre and state government failed to initiate any measures “to save these students from facing injustice in admission” despite knowing that the question papers in Gujarati were more difficult than those in English.

Meanwhile, the Congress has threatened to intensify protests if the government fails to come up with a solution to the issue at the earliest. The opposition party announced that it will participate in the protest march to be held in Ahmedabad on 17 August. Congress leaders would take out rallies in all the districts of Gujarat on August 18 if the issue is not resolved, according to the release.

Centre agrees to exempt Tamil Nadu from NEET

for a year if it passes an Ordinance

NEET : Centre rules out permanent exemption for TN

Sathyanarayana, DH News Service, Chennai, Aug 13 2017

In a setback to Tamil Nadu’s attempt for keeping the National Eligibility and Entrance Test (NEET) away, union minister for Commerce Nirmala Sitharaman on Sunday said that Union government could consider only one-year exemption from the exam if the State promulgates an ordinance.

“Centre cannot give a permanent exemption for Tamil Nadu. The Union Government could co-operate if the State promulgates an ordinance seeking exemption from NEET for one year and that too for the admissions to government colleges only”, the minister said.

Nirmala Sithraman also agreed Tamil Nadu’s data that rural students seeking medical admissions found very difficult to crack NEET. “We have seen the statistics. It shows that rural student’s admissions were very less in government colleges because of the exam. Still, 4,000 students are waiting”, she pointed out.

“I explained everything to our Prime Minister about Tamil Nadu’s position in connection with the NEET. I also asked him to consider the State’s request”, she said.

Stating that Tamil Nadu was facing the unique situation with regard to NEET, the minister advised the State government to bring out curriculum change so that rural students will not find difficult in facing NEET exams. “Special coaching could also be given to them”, she added.

At a time when several states have come under the purview of the NEET, Tamil Nadu was, perhaps, the only state that has been steadfastly opposing it and wanted the present system of admission to medical and dental UG courses based on the Plus-2 marks.


NEET 2017: Allahabad HC asks CBSE to revise

marks awarded to all candidates, decide rank


                                                    Aug, 11 2017

Allahabad: The Allahabad High Court on Thursday directed the CBSE to revise marks awarded to all candidates who had appeared in the NEET exam this year and decide the “merit/rank accordingly” in view of incorrect reply for one of the 180 objective type questions given in the answer key.

Representational image. Getty Images

A division bench comprising Justice Tarun Agarwala and Justice Ashok Kumar passed the order while allowing a writ petition filed by Saumitra Gigodia who had scored 665 out of 720 marks in the National Eligibility cum Entrance Tests for admission to undergraduate medical courses and secured an all India rank of 137.

The petitioner had moved the court with the contention that he was “dismayed to see that the official answer to question no. 172 of test booklet Y was incorrect” following which he “submitted a representation against the OMR grading on payment of Rs 1,000”.

Upon getting no response from the CBSE, the petitioner filed an RTI application which “remained pending” following which he filed the petition “praying for a writ of mandamus commanding the respondents to take a decision on the challenge made by the petitioner” and “to award 05 marks to the petitioner for question no. 172”.

Allowing the petition, the court, however, remarked, “We find that question no. 172 in test booklet code Y could not be answered correctly by any candidate. We are, therefore, of the opinion that in the larger interest of administration the benefit should be extended not only to the petitioner but to all the candidates.”

“The petitioner is entitled to be awarded 05 marks (04 marks for the question and 01 mark for minus marking). We also direct the CBSE to give appropriate marks to all the candidates in the like manner for question no. 172 and corresponding question given in other booklets,” the court added.

“Even though the petitioner had not claimed refund of the prescribed fee for challenging a key answer, since we find that the challenge made by the petitioner was correct we are of the opinion that the petitioner is entitled to a refund of Rs 1,000. We accordingly issue a mandamus commanding the CBSE to refund Rs 1,000 to the petitioner at the earliest,” the court ruled.

NEET 2017: Supreme Court seeks list of qualifying medical students in vernacular

languages from CBSE

 NEET 2017 was held on May 7 and many aspirants, especially from Tamil Nadu

Gujarat and West Bengal, have been complaining about the variations.

The row over the question paper of National Eligibility and Entrance Test (NEET) 2017 doesn’t seem to be getting over. Hearing a plea, the Supreme Court has asked CBSE to submit the list of students who appeared in vernacular languages and have cracked the medical examination.

A petition has been filed by a group of students alleging that the question paper in eight vernacular languages was more difficult than that in English and Hindi. The next hearing in the case is listed for August 8. CBSE has already rejected that there were any variations in the question papers a previous hearing.

NEET 2017 was held on May 7 and many aspirants, especially from Tamil Nadu and West Bengal, have been complaining about the variations.

About 1.48 lakh candidates wrote the exam in eight vernacular languages and the CBSE has said the differences in questions between sets was done to avoid leakage of question papers.

Out of 11.35 lakh aspirants, nearly 6.11 lakh candidates have passed the National Eligibility and Entrance Test (NEET) 2017.

Another petition was filed by a student Alok Tiwari in the apex court demanding cancellation of NEET 2017 result over allegations of question paper leak. The plea sought a CBI inquiry in the matter.


To                                                                       Dated –-27-07-2017
Sri Narendra Modi
Hon’ble Prime Minister
Govt. of India,
Prime Minister’s Office (PMO).
South Block, Raisina Hill, New Delhi, India-110011.

Sub:          Request for exemption of States and Union Territories from NEET   for coming 5 years 

Respected Sir,

With great reverence and humble submission, we would like to draw your kind attention regarding the chaos that occurred in NEET 2017 undergraduate medical entrance test for MBBS and BDS courses, conducted by CBSE, and sufferings of the candidates thereafter.
NEET 2017 was conducted in accordance with IMC amendment Act, 2016. It was expected, as per Law, that a uniform entrance examination will be conducted throughout the nation in different languages. In our vast country, there are at least 36 boards impart 10+2 education with certain variations in their curricula. It was highly expected that CBSE would take common parts of the syllabi to assess merit of those candidates. But unfortunately the CBSE followed its own curriculum and NCERT recommended text books while setting question papers in English and Hindi. Candidates opting for other languages were provided with other set of questions which did neither corroborated with English version nor to their own boards’ curriculum.
As a result, candidates appearing in languages other than English and Hindi scored very poor marks. Situation has gone to the extent when in different states the top scorers in 10 +2 level could not get admission in medical course even in their own state, this time. This is a completely new development and is generating enormous frustration and fuelling up anger not only among the candidates also among the population at large in non-Hindi speaking states, particularly.
Many state governments are now asking for exemption from NEET to stop unjust discrimination and regional political parties are making hue and cry.
NEET was introduced to bring uniformity in standard of the candidates who aspire for medical education. But the current educational scenario in this vast country is far from such uniformity. So long there will be many boards, many curricula and many languages of instruction, success of NEET as the merit marker is unlikely.
Yet, NEET does have its usefulness in current national scenario, viz. for those students who want to go abroad for medical education and want to get admitted at private medical colleges  as well as Deem Universities in India to minimise financial corruption and upliftment of standard of Doctors.
One more point we would like to draw your kind attention that there is a subtle attempt to introduce age bar in medical education, notwithstanding the fact, that the Supreme Court of India had declared such ban  on higher education as unconstitutional.
We earnestly request to your goodness to make necessary arrangement:
i)       For exemption of States and Union Territories from NEET for coming 5 years, and
ii)      For not to introduce age bar in medical education.

Hope, your good office will take necessary action for the benefits of the majority of the students, guardians and people of India.
With best regards,
Yours sincerely,

i) Dr. Amiya Kumar Maity, Formerly attached to SSKM Hospital, Kolkata,
Director, Dr.Maity Educational & Medical Research Ins.Pvt Ltd.
515/1 Lake Gardens, Kolkata-700045, PS – Lake. Ph. No. 9143159986
E.mail :,
ii) Dr. Shankhadip Mula, Formerly attached to P D Hinduja National Hospital, Mumbai, Maharashtra.
iii) Dr. Priyanka Maity, Ex-Medical Officer, M R Bangur Hospital, Kolkata, WB.

Copy to –
i) Mr. Jagat Prakash Nadda The Hon’ble Minister of Health and Family welfare,Govt. of India Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi-110 011011

ii) Prakash Javadekar Hon’ble Minister of HRD, of India New Delhi.

iii) The Minister of State (Health and Family Welfare), Smt Anupriya Patel 09013869482 (M)

iv) Ms. Mamata Banerjee, Hon’ble Chief Minister Govt. of West Bengal.

v) Chief Ministers of all states,

vi) Partha Chatterjee, Hon’ble Higher Education Minister Govt. of West Bengal and of all

vi) Jayshreeben Mehta President of Medical Council of India, President, Medical Council of India Pocket – 14, Sector 8, Dwarka New Delhi – 110077,,

vii) The DME , the Government of West Bengal and all states

viii) The Principal Secretary, Government of West Bengal, Health and Family welfare Dept. and all states.

x) The Chairman, West Bengal Joint Entrance Examinations Board , AQ 13/1, Sector-V, Salt Lake City, Kolkata–700091,

xiv) Others


This entry was posted in News. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest News


Students qualified 10+2 examination with Biology/Biotechnology as 4th subject are eligible to appear NEET (UG) 2018. Only those candidates who have passed Biology/ Bio-technology as an additional subject after passing 10+2 level are not eligible to appear in NEET (UG) … Continue reading

City doc writes to Nadda questioning permit for independent screening test /ENTRANCE TEST (UG) – 2018 (NEET-UG-2018) to be conducted by the Central Board/Replacing the Medical Council Won’t Solve Issues Plaguing India’s Healthcare Community/Terming NEET syllabus unscientific, city doctor writes to Centre /Millennium  POST SC rejects ICARE’s plea to reverse MCI decision to debar college Team MP  23 Sep 2017/ NEET: 97 % MBBS seats have been bagged by students who wrote papers in English PRADIP CHATTERJEE  11 August 2017 | New Delhi

NEET papers to be same for all languages: Javadekar /Puducherry seeks three years exemption from NEET JULY 22, 2017 /NEET jitters for Bengali medium students as number drops drastically this academic session- 20 July 2017 11:31 PM
Continue reading

এই সময়  19-02-2018  পরীক্ষার আগে ডাক্তারির সর্বভারতীয় প্রবেশিকায় আচমকা নতুন নিয়ম ঘিরে সংশয় , বিভ্রান্তি – অনির্বাণ ঘোষ / NEET made mandatory for pursuing medical courses abroad /ডাক্তারি পাঠ্যক্রমের মানচিত্রে নিজভূমে পরবাসী বাংলা মাধ্যমের ছাত্রছাত্রীরা ! এই সময় , Tue, 25 Jul 2017/নিট: রাজ্য সরকারি মেডিকেল কলেজে বাংলা মাধ্যম পড়ুয়ারা পেলেন মাত্র ৭ শতাংশ আসন

                                            এই সময়                                 … Continue reading

MCI’s in-principle approval to bridge course of MBBS after BDS / TAMIL NADU –TheHindu Centre has no right to conduct NEET: Veeramani /Millennium Post  NEET: Centre mulls upper age limit for medical admission, Pradip Chatterjee,20 Oct 2017

Livemint 15 August 2017|E-Paper NEET: Congress wants ordinance for separate merit list of Gujarat students/Centre agrees to exempt Tamil Nadu from NEET for a year if it passes an Ordinance / NEET 2017: Allahabad HC asks CBSE to revise marks awarded to all candidates, decide rank accordingly , Aug, 11 2017 
Continue reading

Number of visitors